
Ep 3: Meet the 12 Tanks - Each a Totally Different Approach to Beating the Uglies and Cycling a Tank
The Biome Cycle experiment was based on twelve individual Red Sea Reefer 170 aquariums that we set up side by side in order to take a closer look at the cycling process and how that ultimately affects the resulting microbiome. Each tank was set up using a slightly different approach to cycling that ranged from sterile dry rock and live rock to sharing biome and media from existing aquariums.












Evaluating Biome Health
The goal was to compare the results in each tank and hopefully gain insight into which methods are the most effective for creating a well-balanced microbiome. In order to do that, we established five different tests or criteria that we used to gauge the health of each of the various resulting biomes.
After all, what does a healthy microbiome look like? We cannot physically see it so the signs or indicators are more complex than a simple observation.
Biome Diversity
We used on Aquabiomics Environmental DNA diversity score which measures how many different organisms make up the microbiome in that particular tank. The tests are performed in the Aquabiomic lab and require water samples to be mailed to the lab directly. All of the results will be shared throughout this BRStv Investigates series.
While most of us believe diversity to be a sign of a healthy aquarium, we found that isn't always the case and only partially true, especially in new aquariums where there is an opportunity for pesky organisms (included in that diversity) to thrive.
Biome Balance
Using the same Aquabiomics Environmental DNA testing, the Biome Balance score provides us with a measure of the good vs. bad in the aquarium and how they compare to each other. The scores are compared against a database of existing aquariums, taking those average scores to create a standard of what a balanced biome looks like.
Visual Results under LPS Lighting (75 -150 PAR)
At the end of the day, we want our tanks to look good. After establishing the tanks without any light, we turned on the Neptune Systems SKY LEDs to provide a level of light and spectrum appropriate for LPS corals for another 6 weeks. We observed the photosynthetic pests that showed up and examined how these visual results correlated to the DNA testing.
Visual Results under SPS Lighting (200 - 350 PAR)
After the LPS lighting, we doubled the light output to hit the PAR range appropriate for SPS and found that a completely different set of photosynthetic pests showed up. These pests also showed up faster which was interesting to see and might tell us more about how the various approaches to cycling may work better in lower or higher light conditions.
Introduction of Pests
Perhaps the most exciting test was our final test of introducing a myriad of pests we collected throughout the office. We created a "pest slurry" and dosed each of the 12 tanks twice and then proceed to see how each tank held up to these introduced pests. Only four tanks were able to withstand the introduction of these pests and we found some interesting shared characteristics that are common in well-established aquariums.
Knowing which approach worked combined with the DNA tracking of the results can help us develop more successful methods and reduce the severity of pests during the initial maturation of a saltwater aquarium. Stay tuned with BRStv as we uncover these methods and share even more exciting discoveries from our Biome Cycle experiment.

Earn 55 Reward Points Earn 165 Reward Points
$11.99
Earn 55 Reward Points Earn 165 Reward Points
$11.99
Earn 234 Reward Points Earn 3,510 Reward Points
$234.00
Earn 1,175 Reward Points Earn 3,525 Reward Points
$235.00
Earn 1,550 Reward Points Earn 4,650 Reward Points
$310.00
Earn 545 Reward Points Earn 1,635 Reward Points
$109.99
Earn 119 Reward Points Earn 1,785 Reward Points
$119.99
Earn 18 Reward Points Earn 270 Reward Points
$18.99
Earn 17 Reward Points Earn 255 Reward Points
$17.99
Earn 18 Reward Points Earn 270 Reward Points
$18.99
Earn 18 Reward Points Earn 270 Reward Points
$18.99
Earn 17 Reward Points Earn 255 Reward Points
$17.99
Earn 18 Reward Points Earn 270 Reward Points
$18.99
Earn 32 Reward Points Earn 480 Reward Points
$32.99
Earn 169 Reward Points Earn 2,535 Reward Points
$169.99
Starting at: $4.00
Earn 20 Reward Points Earn 60 Reward Points

Earn 395 Reward Points Earn 1,185 Reward Points
$79.00
Earn 725 Reward Points Earn 2,175 Reward Points
$145.00
Earn 325 Reward Points Earn 975 Reward Points
$65.00
Earn 395 Reward Points Earn 1,185 Reward Points
$79.00
Earn 795 Reward Points Earn 2,385 Reward Points
$159.00
Earn 1,325 Reward Points Earn 3,975 Reward Points
$265.00
Starting at: $16.49
Earn 16 Reward Points Earn 240 Reward Points

Starting at: $10.15
Earn 10 Reward Points Earn 150 Reward Points

Starting at: $14.05
Earn 14 Reward Points Earn 210 Reward Points

Starting at: $19.99
Earn 19 Reward Points Earn 285 Reward Points

Starting at: $5.99
Earn 25 Reward Points Earn 75 Reward Points

Earn 22 Reward Points Earn 330 Reward Points
$22.07
Starting at: $7.33
Earn 35 Reward Points Earn 105 Reward Points

Earn 590 Reward Points Earn 1,770 Reward Points
$118.99
Earn 365 Reward Points Earn 1,095 Reward Points
$73.99
Earn 265 Reward Points Earn 795 Reward Points
$53.70
Earn 160 Reward Points Earn 480 Reward Points
$32.94
Earn 260 Reward Points Earn 780 Reward Points
$52.48
Earn 165 Reward Points Earn 495 Reward Points
$33.99
Earn 795 Reward Points Earn 2,385 Reward Points
$159.99
Earn 505 Reward Points Earn 1,515 Reward Points
$101.99
Earn 1,060 Reward Points Earn 3,180 Reward Points
$212.99
Earn 1,080 Reward Points Earn 3,240 Reward Points
$216.49
Earn 27 Reward Points Earn 405 Reward Points
$27.99
Starting at: $24.49
Earn 120 Reward Points Earn 360 Reward Points

Earn 38 Reward Points Earn 570 Reward Points
$38.99
Earn 1,110 Reward Points Earn 3,330 Reward Points
$222.99
Earn 815 Reward Points Earn 2,445 Reward Points
$163.99
Earn 100 Reward Points Earn 300 Reward Points
$20.99
Earn 1,995 Reward Points Earn 5,985 Reward Points
$399.99
Starting at: $13.00
Earn 65 Reward Points Earn 195 Reward Points

Starting at: $21.00
Earn 105 Reward Points Earn 315 Reward Points

Starting at: $10.00
Earn 50 Reward Points Earn 150 Reward Points

Starting at: $3.47
Earn 15 Reward Points Earn 45 Reward Points

Earn 165 Reward Points Earn 495 Reward Points
$33.29
Earn 220 Reward Points Earn 660 Reward Points
$44.00
Earn 110 Reward Points Earn 330 Reward Points
$22.00
Earn 110 Reward Points Earn 330 Reward Points
$22.00
Starting at: $14.46
Earn 70 Reward Points Earn 210 Reward Points

Earn 29 Reward Points Earn 435 Reward Points
$29.99
Starting at: $6.99
Earn 6 Reward Points Earn 90 Reward Points

Earn 19 Reward Points Earn 285 Reward Points
$19.99
Earn 33 Reward Points Earn 495 Reward Points
$33.99
Starting at: $10.94
Earn 50 Reward Points Earn 150 Reward Points

Earn 1,645 Reward Points Earn 4,935 Reward Points
$329.99
Earn 1,645 Reward Points Earn 4,935 Reward Points
$329.99
Earn 1,645 Reward Points Earn 4,935 Reward Points
$329.99
Earn 1,645 Reward Points Earn 4,935 Reward Points
$329.99
Earn 63 Reward Points Earn 945 Reward Points
$63.99
Earn 37 Reward Points Earn 555 Reward Points
$37.99
Earn 15 Reward Points Earn 225 Reward Points
$15.99
Earn 1,115 Reward Points Earn 3,345 Reward Points
$223.99
Earn 52 Reward Points Earn 780 Reward Points
$52.99
Earn 52 Reward Points Earn 780 Reward Points
$52.99Categories
BRStv Series
- Aquarium Gear for Beginners
- Beginner's Guide
- BRStv Answers
- BRStv Investigates
- BRStv Problem Solvers
- BRS/WWC Hybrid Method
- Buyer's Guide
- Fish Health
- Master Nutrients: Nitrate, Phosphate and Reef Aquariums
- Neptune Systems Apex Guide
- Product Spotlight & Reviews
- Setup Guide
- Tank Builds
- Tank Profiles & Tours
- Top FAQs
- Top Reefing Mistakes
- Top 10 Tips
- 5 Minute Saltwater Aquarium Guide
Guides & How-Tos
- Additives & Water Chemistry
- Aquarium Controllers
- ATO - Auto Top Off
- Bacteria & Cycling
- BRS Bulk Pharma Additives
- Calcium Reactors
- Coral Propagation & Fragging
- Dosing Pumps
- Filtration & Media
- Fish & Coral Foods
- Heaters & Chillers
- Lighting
- Livestock
- Maintenance
- Plumbing
- Pumps & Water Flow
- Protein Skimmers
- Refugiums
- Reverse Osmosis
- Rock & Sand
- Salt Mix
- Tanks & Sumps
- Test Kits
Charts & Diagrams
Calculators
Problem Solving
Instructions