Useless for reef tanks By Join the Revolution on 9/15/2017
Join the Revolution wouldn't recommend this product to a friend
Use the Hanna ULR for reef tanks in this hobby, not this. Use this for FOWLR or Freshwater only.
Inaccurate readings By Joey on 8/12/2017
Joey wouldn't recommend this product to a friend
I have the Hanna ppm checker and it's pulling weird readings. First .23 ppm then .20 ppm then .15 ppm then .20 ppm then .13 ppm then 0.15 ppm then .19 ppm.... I don't know which is the right reading and I've wasted all my phosphate packets... I made sure there were no bubbles and made sure the powder was dissolved fully.
I contacted Hanna with my concerns. No response yet... :( $50 bucks down the toilet.
Works well on a diffcult test By WP on 6/18/2017
WP would recommend this product to a friend
Hard to get an accurate phosphate test. This one does the job well. I'm testing in freshwater only.
It works for me By Chivo on 6/13/2017
Chivo would recommend this product to a friend
After trying to determine my tank's Phosphates with other kits, I decided to get a Hanna checker and it worked well, and clearly provided feedback to me depending on the actions I was taking. My readings went from 0.08 to 0.03, then 0.01 and finally to 0. I know it works because if I don't change the GFO in my reactor on time, I start getting 0.01-0.02 and when I replace the media it goes back down to 0. It must have a margin of error but I has worked for me.
Two thinks that can be improved from my perspective:
- Timeout is tight and if I'm not on top of my test, the unit will timeout and I have to restart the test.
- It's not easy to get all of the content of the reagent packets into the cuvettes.
Wouldn't recommend for fresh or marine aquarium. By Keith on 5/21/2017
Keith wouldn't recommend this product to a friend
This unit is great in theory but can't be counted on for accuracy under any stretch of the imagination. It test's 0-00 on my reef tank when that's qualitatively impossible for the condition. I've tested my tap water and only find 0.43 while the city says it runs on average 0.80. Tested other tanks with results of 0.00 when other test kits show trace amounts. Took my water to a local chemical test lab and found phosphate to be 0.02. I understand the accuracy, repeatability and reproducibility issues but shouldn't always be on the - side instead of +/-. I'm not particularly impressed with Salifert but it was the closest to Salifert. At least close enough to manage a marine aquarium.
Confused for why it is continuing reading 0.0 ppm By Jonathan on 4/5/2017
Jonathan wouldn't recommend this product to a friend
I have had this product for about a month or 2 now and it keeps on reading 0.0, Not sure if i have a one that is broken. I will give a future review.
Excellent - reliable and accurate By Mitch on 3/6/2017
Mitch would recommend this product to a friend
I really think this is the best test kit you can buy for Phosphates. It gives you a very accurate reading and it gets the job done in about 5 minutes. Simple to use. I would though prefer the regent to be liquid than powder but other than that small detail this is a great item and I would recommend it to any hobbyist who wants an accurate reading.
Easy and quick By Rob on 12/8/2016
Rob would recommend this product to a friend
This was my first HANNA checker purchase. Ive been hearing all the rage about these for a while so i finally tried. Very east and simple to use. Less then 5 minutes to test and get results. Definitely will be trying a few other HANNA checkers now.
**Be Aware** Not Suitable For Reef Aquarium Testing! By Julio on 10/16/2016
Julio wouldn't recommend this product to a friend
Not sure why Hanna doesn't just Discontinue this product even though they know it's more suited for "Fresh" water than marine usage. I've owned this for 6 months and never had the digits read above 0.00 ppm! Had the signs apparently of having phosphates with algae growing constantly on my glass! Went and purchased RedSea's Phosphate test kit and Salifert's test kit just to make sure and too my surprise not only I had phosphates present in my reef tank but that the results showed RedSea 0.8 ppm Salifert 0.07 but yet my Hanba HI-713 can not detect these units! I emediatly called Hanna Headquarters in Smithfield Rhode Island and to my surprise, they told me that the HI-736 ULR which is the "Ultra Low Reading" test kit would be more suitable for me, which really indicates that thier aware of this problem! IMO, maybe they just never made an attempt to recall this model of kit in in order to save tons of money they just went ahead and slapped on the "Fresh & Marine " label and kept it as is but clearly if you don't see a "Fish" label in front of your handheld with the "Marine" label as well than it's not suitable for Marine! Unfortunately this problem is not going away! Reefers Be Advised, purchase the ULR instead!
The product it's really easy to use By Joseph on 10/2/2016
Joseph would recommend this product to a friend
Hanna Phosphate Low Range Colorimeter works well . Fast and accurate