Red Sea vs. API By James on 10/30/2011
James wouldn't recommend this product to a friend
@AC2020x, why do you think Red Sea gives better results than API? Have you have Red Sea results compared to the results from an independent scientific lab, or are you just guessing?
Good product.. very accurate results By Scott on 10/29/2011
Scott would recommend this product to a friend
The method of counting the amount of titration to get your levels is much better than judging what color the solution is compared to the card. It is expensive compared to the ATI kits but worth it for the hard to measure chemicals. I don't think I would get this expensive of a kit for nitrites / nitrates and stuff that is usually zero in my tank at least. If you have problems with those though you should get Red Sea kits for everything to chart an accurate number to see what is going on in your tank.
Don't buy any other brand By Jay on 10/27/2011
Jay would recommend this product to a friend
I am completely sold on Red Sea products - the test kits are so easy to use, the measure down the 0.01 ml scale which is very accurate; They are worth any extra cost they may incur.
Easy to Use By Bob A on 10/19/2011
Bob A would recommend this product to a friend
If this doesn't change the way you test water, then you aren't interested in simplicity. This test kit, with the titrator, makes life so much easier. You wont be sorry you bought this
Read the instructions! By Michael on 10/14/2011
Michael would recommend this product to a friend
I tried to test the water twice using just the visual cards that came with the kit with no change in color. I read the instructions and found that I was skipping an important step. Definitely read the instructions first! After I figured out my problem, the test kit works great.
High Quality Test Kit By AC2020x on 10/8/2011
AC2020x would recommend this product to a friend
I definitely suggest red sea pro test kits to everyone who is looking to keep an accurate check on these parameters. I used API tests for quite some time and although they are alright for getting a general ideas of what your parameters are.. they are just unmatched compared to these accurate results. The methods of testing are very scientific as well which is great for testing accurately and not messing up somewhere ruining your entire test.
Although it is a bit more expensive that API tests... they are very high quality and def. worth it in my opinion. If you are just looking to keep a few corals alive though.. this accuracy may not be for you. But if you want your corals to thrive under accurate parameters.. then i believe that you need an accurate test kit... I have gotten very reliable and non-varying numbers that I have experienced with some other test kits.
Also there are refills available which is great for it you run out or if your tests expire. Over time this will allow the tests to be cheaper.... Also the videos are great cause they show you exactly how you want to test so you don't get the wrong results!
its ok By Charles on 10/7/2011
Charles wouldn't recommend this product to a friend
wanted to try this kit like everyone else who watched the video. Its ok. pros: love the packaging, love the organization, love the titration holder. cons: the syringes are not smooth during titration, the graduations on the syringe should be reversed, the instructions aren't the greatest. truth be told, I'm not much a fan of most tests. i kike the Salifert calcium test more than this one though. the syringe is just a paim to use in the titration holder.
must have By jeffrey on 10/4/2011
jeffrey would recommend this product to a friend
red sea tests are very easy and convinent, and a great price. these are the main three tests you should really have
Awsome test Kit By Hathamat on 10/2/2011
Hathamat would recommend this product to a friend
This test kit is definitely Worth the money spent on it. Easy to use accurate and a good value. Easily the best test kit I have purchased.
Good product By ShawnCC on 9/28/2011
ShawnCC would recommend this product to a friend
This kit works well, and has a professional feel to it. It's much easier to titrate with this system, as you don't have to worry about spilling while you're stirring it up. I am very much a fan of having mutliple tests bundled into one kit, so that when you're done with it, you can pack it away in a single case and store it.
A few suggestions for Red Sea:
- I would prefer it if the case were hinged, or had some sort of better closing mechanism. Because it doesn't securely "snap" shut, attempting to pick it up by the lid (i.e. when you're taking it out of the packaging box) causes the lid to come right off.
- Because the contents of the kit have such a tight fit, I find it difficult to get the lid back on when I'm done with it. I typically have to rearrange the contents and make several attempts. An improvement would be having a designated spot, within the case, for each component. For example, each syringe could snap into a special spot, so that it's consistently organized, and the box is easier to close, instead of having it all tossed in there.
Please note that these gripes about about the case only, and the *actual* product--the tests themselves--are very good. I would recommend.
One final suggestion to Red Sea: I notice that you don't have a basic saltwater test kit for Ammonia + Nitrite + Nitrate + pH (the standard cycling parameters). I would really love it if you made such a kit that makes use of your colorimetric comparator.
Don't mind doing the test now By tonythefish on 9/22/2011
tonythefish would recommend this product to a friend
Works great and seems to be accurate . look forward to just buying the refills
Almost perfect By tommyboynj on 9/19/2011
tommyboynj would recommend this product to a friend
This is a solid test kit and a fantastic deal if you buy the foundations kit. I was looking to add a magnesium test to my supplies. Up until about 6 weeks ago I had just been test calcium and alkalinity as part of my weekly testing routine. As my tank has matured I noticed I was going to need to keep my mag in check also. Up until I purchased this kit I had been using api kits for all my testing. I found the red sea kit very accurate with easy to follow insructions. Everything is color coded also which is nice. My only complaint would that the color transitions during the test can be alittle hard to determine. I generally found with the api kits the color change was dramatic giving clear indication of the test being complete. Other than that I loved the kit. Well packaged and easy to use.