Results within range of accuracy By Stratos on 5/2/2016
Stratos would recommend this product to a friend
Although the Kh tester is much easier and straight forward this guy is a little trickier. The trickiest part of all is the reagent pouches that have to be emptied and I suspect that's the biggest factor of error. A lot of people complain about it's readings but the kit does say " ±6% of reading" which means that for a reading of 420 ppm the error is ±25 ppm. I find that acceptable since titration tests are hard to read especially for my eyes. All in all, the only thing I would suggest changing is the dispensing of the solid reagent.
Questionable accuracy By Larry on 4/25/2016
Larry would recommend this product to a friend
While I LOVE the Hanna Alkalinity tester - I have issues with the Calcium tester.
I ALWAYS test 2-3 times and will usually get 2-3 different results - sometimes VERY different.
Which means I am going through the reagent very fast.
It IS easier than the Red Sea kit but, If you don't get consistent results then you can't trust it. And if you can't trust it then why even bother.
Incredibly Useless By Ray on 4/16/2016
Ray wouldn't recommend this product to a friend
I hate titration, but this test wins. First it was wildly inaccurate, probably because you need a full lab with bright lights, deionized water, and a way to empty the packet without spilling or breathing, and get it in a hole the size of a pencil. Return to sender this thing sucks. The test showed 200, red sea daily tests show 390. If they could find a way to dispense the packet, the show scissors cutting around it entirely like you would empty it into a stainless mixing tray with a pour spout or something. Then the syringe is barely readable except under metal halides. Ya, do not waste your money on this one. I love their KH though.
Not accurate or consistent. By Rick on 4/13/2016
Rick wouldn't recommend this product to a friend
I had high hopes that this kit would make testing easier. I even bought another Hanna checker before this one even arrived. First, I've been reef keeping for nearly 20 years.
I checked against two other test kits, both Salifert. Both kits said 390 +-6 over 2 tests each. Hanna said 361, then 470. That makes this test kit useless.
Hanna, if you can fix the accuracy and consistency, I have a few suggestions. First, the packets are ok, but a scoop works just fine for me on the Salifert kits. For current users: I figured out quickly that opening the packet with scissors across one side then open it wide to form a nice sharp point makes is easy to get into the vial.
I don't like the dropper to get the DI water into the vial. I remember high school/college chemistry. So, I knew to put the line at the half bubble of the water. A 10ml syringe would make that step easy. And possibly more accurate?
Lastly, I'm only 44 so my eyes are still pretty good, but the instructions are in 2pt font. The box is big enough that I think a bigger font would easily fit in the box... and be kinder to the user.
Checks calcium, no better than others By ryan on 3/14/2016
ryan wouldn't recommend this product to a friend
It's expensive and cool. It works, but my Red Sea test is actually more accurate and the testing process is nearly identical.
Now that I have it and compare the two side by side, I regret buying it. I'm not bashing Hanna Checkers, I would love to get more, but this one is one I will be selling because I won't be using it.
Spend more time enjoying your REEF & LESS time testing By DAVID on 3/1/2016
DAVID would recommend this product to a friend
I have used API, and Red Sea in the past.I found Red Sea to be pretty accurate but this one gives the the exact reading which I would rather have then trying to figure what it is with Red Sea. I feel that with this testers, you can enjoy your reef tank more. I am going to get as many Hanna testers that I can get but will still have no choice to use some with Red Sea, which is fine with me.
Great Tool By Peter on 1/6/2016
Peter would recommend this product to a friend
The Hanna Checker is a great investment. It is so much easier to use than test kits. I have been using it while setting up my dosing system and testing it against a Salfert test kit, I have stopped with the kit and rely on the hanna checker.
Best option available By jsbull on 1/2/2016
jsbull would recommend this product to a friend
This is a pretty involved test, so I don't like doing it, but this is accurate and the best I've found. I did screw up the first time, but have not had issues since I got the hang of the directions.
Good test kit By Eric on 12/27/2015
Eric would recommend this product to a friend
Overall good, but like others, the reagent could be better than the little packets.
Exellent By Virgil on 11/30/2015
Virgil would recommend this product to a friend
I was weary of buying this checker after reading a lot of the bad reviews, but after receiving it, I tested my water 5 times back to back. With the red sea test reading 450ppm, my results were 454, 451, 458, 447, and 451. If you take your time and measure precise you will be very pleased as I am!